While garbage disposals can be loud and seem a bit threatening based on their design and operation, proper use and installation makes garbage disposal accidents extremely unlikely. Preventative measures are the most effective and perhaps the most obvious ways to mitigate the risk of owning and operating a garbage disposal unit.
They include (but should not be limited to) the following:
- Keep all hands and fingers away from unit while in operation
- Avoid dropping anything heavy, metal, or generally hard into the unit
- Use a rubber cover over the sink hole (most garbage disposals come with one)
- Only operate the unit according to instructions and for recommended waste substances
If you follow these safety measures, the risk of a garbage disposal-related injury is very low. Yet, when operating any kind of kitchen appliance or machine, the potential for physical trauma is still something that needs to be considered.
Just like you would take care when using a blender or even an electric can opener, you should do the same when using a garbage disposal unit.
Potential for Physical Trauma
It's important to note that garbage disposals are not suction devices. In other words, they do not pull things down into the spinners. You should also keep in mind that most units are designed with a pulverizing mechanism that is the first contact point, meaning a hand or limb would experience blunt force trauma before heavy laceration would occur.
For this to happen, a person would have to intentionally make contact with the spinners and then maintain that contact without withdrawing their hand or limb. The unit would not forcibly pull you in.
Still, there's potential for the following injuries:
- Broken Bones
- Lacerations and deep tissue damage
Users should also be mindful about foreign items that might get stuck in a garbage disposal that aren't meant to be there. Of course the most common of these items would be a metal kitchen utensil which often ends up in a sink alongside food waste, which can result in similar injuries, especially without a sink hole cover.
In extremely rare cases, garbage disposal units have been recalled because of defective parts that could potentially become detached from the spinning component, like this garbage disposal that was recalled by Anaheim and Moen.
Concerns with Environmental Impact
The city of New York actually banned the user of garbage disposal units in the 1970s, before eventually commissioning a study of their effects on public waste water in 1995. This would lead to the rescinding of the ban in 1997. The city of Raleigh North Carolina attempted a similar ban in 2008 that was quickly rescinded after only one month.
The environmental impact on your home and kitchen is demonstrably positive.
While there are still studies being conducted to help better understand the impacts of garbage disposals on the public sewer system (there are a wide range of benefits here as well), it's widely accepted that they're a net-positive for the environment within your own home. In other words, it's safer and cleaner to dispose of food waste quickly, via the sewer system, then it is to try and keep it in your trash can (inside or out) until that trash can be removed.
In this regard, the environmental impact on your home and kitchen is demonstrably positive.
Safe Operation of a Garbage Disposal
Always run your garbage disposal with cold water and avoid switching it on before confirming that all foreign objects are away from the sink hole and that the disposal itself is empty.
Here's a bulleted list of safety measures:
- Always use with cold running water
- Ensure no foreign objects (metal, glass, etc.) are in the garbage disposal before or during its operation
- Avoid any and all physical contact with the garbage disposal before, during, and after operation
- Make sure the garbage disposal is unplugged before attempting to unclog or perform any kind of maintenance on the unit
You can get garbage disposals now that actually have a safer cover. The most common (and the original design) is the Insinkerator Evolution Cover Control.
It's expensive, but perhaps worth the investment if you want a safer garbage disposal alternative.
You can read more about the development of the Cover Control from CNET.
Other options for reducing risk would be closely linked with the above recommendations for safe operation. It's really a matter of taking basic steps to carefully operate the unit and avoid careless mistakes. If you do that, the odds of injury are extremely low.
If you want to shop around for other units that at least have the traditionally rubber cover, checkout our best garbage disposal roundup article.
To wrap up our discussion on whether or not garbage disposals are safe, it's important to reiterate that careful operation is going to mitigate most of the risk involved. Just like you would take care when using a blender or even an electric can opener, you should do the same when using a garbage disposal unit.
If you do that, garbage disposals are safe by all objective measurements, and unlikely to cause any kind of injury.
Additional Garbage Disposal Resources
AUTHOR: Ryan is a DIYer, homeowner, and general fan of a clean, good-smelling kitchen.