Garbage Disposal Laws: What are they?

What are the garbage disposal laws that United States residents need to be concerned about? Since we live in Virginia, and are currently looking at buying a new garbage disposal, I decided to do a little research on this topic, which is surprisingly political. Given their environmental impact, garbage disposals have been a topic of debate in the past and have even been illegal in certain cities. In Raleigh North Carolina, they were banned as recently as 2008.

The same thing happened in New York in the 1970s.

While that's not the case today, it can still be helpful to be aware of the political and "waste management" guidelines surrounding garbage disposals.

Capturing and Converting Methane

The first thing of note isn't really a law as much as it's a look back at why garbage disposals are now viewed as a better alternative to traditional waste control methods. Since the contents of a garbage disposal waste are usually around 90 percent water, it's far easier for local and state governments to filter and clean the contents, converting the non-water material into capturable methane gas and recycling the water back into public systems.

While methane gas is also produced by food waste in landfills, it's much trickier to capture, leaving much of it released into the open air, instead of kept as bio fuel.

This is some of the reasoning behind why older laws that prohibited garbage disposals were eventually repealed. The original concern was along the lines of worrying that there would be food waste floating in the water supply, which was absolutely false.

New York Code Concerning Septic Systems

New York City Fifth Avenue Graphic

While you can buy garbage disposals that are more ideal for septic tanks, they are still inherently hard on septic systems. 

For that reason, some states will have more strict guidelines surrounding their use in conjunction with a septic system that needs to be pumped. For example, the New York state septic code views a garbage disposal as an entire extra room, when determining load on a corresponding septic tank.

Most other states have minor regulations and standards built into home inspection standards which we'll cover in the following section

Part of a Home Inspection

Most of the home inspection issues surrounding a garbage disposal are just common sense. For example, wiring needs to be done correctly and the disposal needs to have an adequate source of water. A home inspector will (should) also inspect a garbage disposal for leaks by running water through it.

Again, these are not necessarily what you would consider laws.

However, they do have some legal implications if you want to sell or buy a house with a garbage disposal. In most cases, a leaky disposal will fail a home inspection.


In conclusion, prohibitive garbage disposal laws have largely been done away with. You need to be careful with septic systems, and you also need to make sure your unit has been properly installed and is in good working order for a pending home inspection.

Otherwise, garbage disposals have been embraced as a convenient, effective, and environmentally-positive way to eliminate food waste from your home.

In other words, it's a better way to clean up.

If you have questions about garbage disposal laws, leave it in the comments section below and we'll do our best to help out.

Additional Garbage Disposal Resources

Do garbage disposals get full? (simple answer)
Garbage disposals are a modern convenience that many of us rely to make kitchen cleanup easier. But as we throw food[...]
9 Maintenance Tips for Your Garbage Disposal
In this article we'll cover some simple ways to extend the life of your garbage disposal. Regular maintenance will help[...]
InSinkErator Evolution Compact Price Guide (updated live)
Article updated by Molly on June 23rd, 2023 / Updated the API price table to pull the InSinkErator Evolution compact prices[...]
Best Waste King Garbage Disposal? (Our Top Pick)
Article updated by Molly on June 23rd, 2023 / Added the price guide for the Waste King L-8000 and made some[...]
Garbage Disposal Feed Types: Continuous Feed VS Batch Feed
When choosing a garbage disposal for your kitchen, there are primarily two feed types: Continuous feed Batch feed Each type[...]
Best Garbage Disposal for a Deep Sink (our top picks)
Article updated by Molly on July 7th, 2022 / Checked product links and made some updates to the copy. If you[...]

4 thoughts on “Garbage Disposal Laws: What are they?

    • WHAT? That’s so bizarre. So they’re illegal to use but you must have them installed? Good grief. Not sure what to tell you there.

  • We live in Ontario Calif where a new law has been implemented….putting waste that we usually put in a garbage disposal now has to be put in bags and not down a disposal…, my question is, we just bought a very expensive new garbage disposal……shall we install it or return it to Home Depot since we can’t put stuff in it anymore?

    • Dang. Well, I guess that all depends on how Cali is going to enforce the law. My guess is that you could get away with using it for awhile, but who knows. I guess I would go ahead and return it.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Click outside to hide the comparison bar